Your expert guide to cybersecurity and digital privacy.
Security hardening for all platforms : Windows, macOS, Linux, and Android.
Solutions aligned standards : NIST and ANSSI for comprehensive digital protection.
Big Tech Enshittification 2025-2026: GAFAM Decay Explained
Big Tech Enshittification — Deliberate platform decay 2025-2026 | SafeITExperts.com
-61%
Organic clicks killed by Google AI Overviews
Source: InFront Marketing / Seer Interactive 2025
0,50€
Apple's charge per EU app install (Core Technology Fee)
Source: Apple Developer Program 2024
77%
Amazon's US retail ad market dominance in 2025
Source: eMarketer Amazon Ad Revenue 2025
10$/mois
Microsoft Teams Premium — live translated captions paywalled
Source: Microsoft Teams Pricing
-60%
LinkedIn creators reach lost — 360Brew algorithm
Source: Sheza Yazdani / Tracy Enos 2025
3
Doctorow phases — universal decay mechanism
Source: Cory Doctorow, Pluralistic 2022
⏱️ Reading time: 18 min · All figures are sourced and verifiable
Introduction: Welcome to the Era of Programmed Decay
2026. You type "best VPN" on Google → an AI answer, zero clicks to websites. LinkedIn → your posts seen by 3 followers out of 100. EU iPhone → AirPods translation blocked. Teams → live translated captions? €10/month.
A platform is nice to users, then it abuses suppliers to keep users happy, then finally it abuses users to claw back value for shareholders.
— Cory Doctorow, who coined the term enshittification (2022)
This is not a bug — it's phase 2 of enshittification. Cory Doctorow predicted in 2022: once the monopoly is secured, digital giants deliberately degrade their services to maximize profits. 2025-2026 confirms the prophecy.
In this article
Google, Meta, Apple, Amazon, Microsoft. 8 chapters, 8 concrete mechanisms, verified figures with clickable sources. By the end, you'll know how to resist — and which alternatives to choose.
1
Enshittification — The Unspoken Monopoly Playbook
Why are your favorite apps becoming unbearable? Since 2025, you feel it every day: Google gives you AI answers instead of links, LinkedIn buries your posts, Apple charges for features that were free, Amazon hides your products behind its opaque Buy Box. This is a calculated strategy, named enshittification by Cory Doctorow.
User exodus, regulatory intervention — often too late given the barriers. Bluesky, EU DMA, Mastodon.
The Economic Principle
Once the monopoly is secured, it is more profitable to exploit existing users than to attract new ones. This is the classic "cash cow" — and AI will amplify everything in 2026.
Imagine: you type "best VPN 2026". Before, Google gave you 10 links to explore. Today? A complete AI answer, with no reason to click elsewhere. That's AI Overviews + Search Generative Experience (SGE). Google no longer guides you to the web — it is the web.
These queries already had historically low CTRs (zero-click searches). Google didn't invent the problem — it institutionalized it to the benefit of its own ads and internal services.
SEO vs GEO: The Great Divide
Approach
Mechanism
Beneficiaries
📝 Traditional SEO
E-E-A-T + original content → clicks to your site
Independent publishers
🤖 GEO (Generative Engine Optimization)
"AI-friendly" content → citation in AI Overview → indirect traffic
Giants (Forbes, NYT, established brands)
Consequence: small publishers die. Giants adapt by publishing "AI-prompt" content. The December 2025 Core update rewards structured schemas and coherent entities — at the expense of originality.
Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp: you thought this was "uncontrolled chaos"? Think again. Meta deliberately tolerates certain fraudulent content because the ad revenue it generates exceeds the cost of moderation.
Calculated Tolerance: The Numbers
Content type
Example
Why Meta tolerates it
🇨🇳 Chinese scam operations
Miracle loans, fake investments
Massive ad revenue — estimated at ~20% of Chinese ad revenue
🎰 Offshore gambling advertising
Unregulated online casinos
Strong demand, little applicable regulation
🏪 Ghost e-commerce stores
Products never delivered
Easy account creation — moderation is expensive
Admitted strategy
Meta "cleans up" just enough to avoid regulatory fines, but not enough to kill the golden goose of ad revenue. A cynical but economically rational trade-off.
The Facebook Groups API: The Final Blow to Developers
Apple facing the EU DMA: you thought regulation would open the App Store? With Machiavellian genius, Apple transformed a legal constraint into a new revenue stream — the infamous malicious compliance.
The DMA Turned Against Its Own Goals
Apple measure
Detail
Concrete impact
💶 Core Technology Fee (CTF)
€0.50 per annual install after 1M installs
Prohibitive cost for popular free apps
💰 Reduced commissions
10-17% instead of 30% + external link fees 3-5%
Fee complexity — sometimes more expensive than before
🧩 Fee complexity
Opaque calculations, changing conditions
Actively discourages alternatives
This is malicious compliance.
— Tim Sweeney, Epic Games, reacting to Apple's CTF
Amazon dominates 77% of US retail ad spending in 2025. You're a seller? You're dancing on a volcano. The Buy Box — that little "Add to Cart" box everyone clicks — has become an opaque oracle that arbitrarily decides who lives, who dies.
The Algorithmic Buy Box Mechanism
Factor
Official weight
Ground reality
💰 Price
High
Context-dependent — compared to poorly listed external products
📦 Shipping cost
Medium
Opaque
🚚 Delivery speed
~30% of score
Confirmed by Amazon
⭐ Seller reputation
High
1-star competitors win — documented cases
📊 Review volume/rate
Medium
Opaque
Seller Testimonials 2025 (Seller Central Sources)
I lost the Buy Box on 15 ASINs. Lower price, Prime, 4.8 stars. My competitor? 1 star, 7-day delivery, $90 fees. They won.
— UK Seller, Amazon Seller Central Forum, November 2025
Amazon compares with poorly listed external products. Our €50 product is compared to €30 on Billiger.de with a different photo.
— German Seller, Amazon Seller Central Forum, December 2025
The perfect black box
Amazon never responds to Buy Box disputes. The algorithm is impossible to officially optimize, impossible to contest. The only solution? Pay for Amazon advertising.
Microsoft found the magic formula: make AI indispensable while paywalling your everyday tools. Teams, Copilot, LinkedIn — every service follows the same pattern: what you had for free becomes premium, under the guise of AI.
Teams Premium: Deliberate Degradation
Feature
Before
After
Cost
🎤 Real-time translated captions
Free
Paid
$10/user/month
⏱️ Recording timeline markers
Free
Paid
Included in Premium
📊 Organizational analytics
Free
Paid
Included in Premium
Degradation by design
Your free Teams is intentionally impoverished. Not paying = reduced productivity. Economic friction creates pressure without explicitly forbidding anything.
Copilot: "Pay or Stagnate"
Copilot feature
Benefit
Enterprise cost
📝 Automatic meeting summaries
Significant time savings
30$/utilisateur/mois
📊 AI-assisted PowerPoint generation
Increased productivity
📈 AI Excel analysis
Advanced analyses accessible
LinkedIn 360Brew: The Algorithm Killing Discovery
Late 2025: LinkedIn deploys 360Brew, an algorithm that analyzes the semantic meaning of content.
Enshittification is not abstract. It affects you directly. Everyday users, content creators, third-party developers, marketplace sellers — each pays the price of Big Tech's strategic degradation.
The European DMA was supposed to liberate the digital world. Result? Apple made more money, Europeans got fewer features. Welcome to the world of malicious compliance — when giants follow the letter of the law to better violate its spirit.
The DMA Paradox: Opening to Better Close
DMA objective
Targets
Big Tech response
Result
📲 Force sideloading
Apple, Google
Core Technology Fee €0.50/install
Prohibitive cost
💳 External payments
Apple, Google, Meta
3-5% fees + complexity
Discouragement
🔨 Break the "gatekeepers"
All Big Tech
Partial compliance + war of attrition
War of attrition
DMA — Real Winners and Losers
Player
DMA intent
2026 result
🍏 Apple
Loss of 30% commissions
CTF + complex fees = profitable status quo
🇪🇺 EU Users
More choice and features
Features removed — AirPods translation, Maps
🎮 Epic / AltStore
Access to iOS market
Surviving — but fragile
👨💻 Small developers
New alternative stores
Stifled by fees — Setapp closed
🏛️ Regulators
Control the gatekeepers
War of attrition — Big Tech 2000+ lawyers vs 200 EU jurists
The Structural Limits of Regulation
Problem
Detail
Consequence
⏱️ Slowness
DMA adopted 2022 → full effect 2026
Big Tech adapted in 3 months, regulators in 4 years
Here we are. Big Tech has locked in their monopolies and activated phase 2: controlled degradation. Google synthesizes your competitors, Apple charges for the air you breathe, Amazon makes you invisible without ads, Microsoft sells AI as indispensable, Meta tolerates fraudulent chaos. Your digital experience gets worse — and it's profitable.
The Scorecard in 8 Numbers (2025-2026)
Indicator
Value
Source
📉 Organic clicks — Google AI Overviews
-61%
InFront / Seer Interactive 2025
📊 LinkedIn 360Brew creator reach
-30% to -60%
Sheza Yazdani / Tracy Enos 2025
💶 Apple Core Technology Fee per EU install
0,50€
Apple Developer Program
📅 Facebook Groups API removed
Jan. 2024
Meta Graph API Changelog
🛒 Amazon US retail ad market
77%
eMarketer 2025
💼 Microsoft Teams Premium
10$/mois
Microsoft Teams Pricing
🤖 Microsoft Copilot enterprise
30$/mois
Microsoft 365 Copilot
📱 Setapp Mobile
Closed (Feb. 2026)
MacPaw Official
Three Scenarios for 2027
📊
Status quo
Probability: High. Big Tech → aggressive AI, regulation → war of attrition, you → trapped in ecosystems.
The era of resignation is over. The era of bifurcation begins.
Diversify your tools, reduce your dependency on Big Tech, and support open alternatives. Every click on DuckDuckGo, every post on Mastodon, every algorithm-free newsletter is a concrete act of resistance.
📚 Enshittification Glossary — 8 Key Terms
Enshittification
Deliberate post-monopoly degradation of a digital platform to maximize profits at the expense of users.
2026 example: Google AI Overviews eliminating traffic to publishers.
SGE / AI Overviews
Search Generative Experience: AI-generated answers integrated into Google Search that eliminate the need to click through to sites.
2026 example: "Best VPN" → complete answer, zero clicks.
Core Technology Fee (CTF)
Apple's fee of €0.50 per annual install in the EU beyond one million installs, introduced in response to the DMA.
2026 example: Setapp Mobile closed due to CTF costs.
Buy Box
The "Buy Now" zone on Amazon, controlled by an opaque algorithm that decides which seller wins the sale.
2026 example: 4.8★ seller losing to a 1★ competitor with no explanation.
360Brew
LinkedIn algorithm deployed in late 2025 analyzing semantic content coherence, penalizing engagement bait.
2026 example: Average creators losing -60% reach.
Malicious compliance
Strategy of following the letter of a law while violating its spirit, making compliance counterproductive.
2026 example: Apple allowing sideloading but via prohibitive CTF.
GEO
Generative Engine Optimization: content optimization to be cited in AI answers (AI Overviews) rather than to obtain clicks.
2026 example: Classic SEO → GEO to survive in the post-SGE era.
Sludge
User experience deliberately polluted and slowed by friction, ads and parasitic content to maximize engagement or revenue.
2026 example: 2026 Facebook/Instagram feed saturated with ads and tolerated scams.
❓ Enshittification FAQ — 7 Questions
1 Why is Google killing my organic clicks?
AI Overviews (SGE) synthesize answers directly in Google results, eliminating the need to click through to sites. 2025 studies (InFront Marketing, Seer Interactive) show a decline of -15% to -70% organic CTR depending on the query — comparisons and tutorials being the hardest hit. Google no longer guides you to the web: it is now the web, capturing 100% of attention time to push you toward its advertising.
2 Did the European DMA really fail against Apple?
Partially. Apple practiced malicious compliance: allowing sideloading — a legal obligation — while introducing a Core Technology Fee of €0.50 per annual install beyond the first million. For a popular free app with 10M installs/year, that's €4.5M/year in fees. Some breakthroughs did work: Epic Games Store and AltStore PAL are available on iOS in Europe. But Setapp Mobile closed in February 2026, a victim of those same fees.
3 Do I need to pay for Microsoft Copilot to stay competitive?
No, but Microsoft creates asymmetric social pressure: companies adopting Copilot ($30/month/user) gain a perceived edge — automatic summaries, presentation generation — that pushes competitors to follow. This is the same logic as Teams Premium ($10/month) which paywalls free features like translated captions. Resist if you can; open source alternatives exist (LibreOffice AI, Nextcloud AI, local tools).
4 Does Amazon favor its own products in the Buy Box?
The Buy Box algorithm is opaque by design. Third-party sellers document losing the Buy Box to lower-rated, slower and more expensive competitors — with no explanation provided by Amazon. The exact weighting of criteria is not public. What is certain: sellers using FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon) and Amazon advertising are statistically advantaged, creating a vicious cycle of Amazon dependency to exist on Amazon.
5 Is LinkedIn 360Brew really unfair to creators?
360Brew legitimately targets semantic imprecision and engagement bait (FIRE, "like if you agree"). But the concrete effect centralizes reach toward Premium accounts and established brands. Average creators lose -30% to -60% reach, while large accounts benefit from the algorithm. The nuance: 360Brew objectively improves the overall quality of LinkedIn's feed. The criticism: it transforms LinkedIn into a two-speed platform.
6 How can I concretely resist enshittification?
Personal level (immediate impact): DuckDuckGo or Perplexity for search · Signal/Element for messaging · Substack for content creation · Shopify/Etsy for selling · ProtonMail for email.
Business/blog level: Diversify your audience (40% Google, 30% LinkedIn, 30% owned newsletter) · Optimize for GEO + SEO · Self-hosting to reclaim your data. See our guides at SafeITExperts.com.
7 Will AI amplify enshittification in 2026-2027?
Yes, very probably. AI enables Big Tech to: synthesize your content without paying you (Google AI Overviews) · sell "essential" tools at $30/month (Copilot) · predict your behavior with growing precision (Amazon). Algorithmic dependency accelerates as AI integrates into every platform layer. Resistance lies in decentralization, self-hosting, and supporting open source alternatives before network effects condemn them.
🔗 Verified Sources — All Article References
SafeITExperts Methodology
Primary sources only · Verified March 2026 · Links tested and working · 2+ sources per cited figure · Dated 2024-2026 (current)